Monthly Archives: September 2014
Disappointing reasons to vote No
A response to Ewan Morrison’s “Yes: Why I joined and why I changed to No“.Ewan Morrison discusses why he was turned off the Yes campaign. To summarize, as faithfully as I can:(1) Morrison joined the Yes camp in the hope of finding some debate. Instead he got rah-rah. People were not interested in hearing awkward questions […]
Infantilisation of the electorate
The subtext of some of the key arguments against a ‘Yes’ vote is infantalising. For example:‘You shouldn’t be supporting a vainglorious leader/party’ i.e. Alex Salmond/SNP. ‘You won’t have a currency union, and there’s no Plan B’. Even if these are true (and the second one certainly is), why is that a reason to vote ‘No’? Basically […]
Sham investment bank research
European monetary union represents a major step on the road to European integration. The euro will promote not only economic prosperity but also political stability by leading to intensified cooperation among the countries of Europe, a stronger focus on common interests and the establishment of common institutions to help solve conflicts. Deutsche Bank Research (1998), […]
Small states > Big states
In 1957 in his classic book The Breakdown of Nations economist and political scientist Leopold Kohr persuasively and rigorously argued that small nations are the natural order having been throughout history the engines for enlightenment, innovation, mutual aid and the arts. The large nation state, he argued, is not a reflection of improved efficiency but […]
Scotland
I can’t say how I’d vote “if I were a Scot”. If I were a Scot, I wouldn’t be me. But I can tell you my opinion: Yes; for independence. Better still, I can address the currency question.On the politics, George Mombiot makes the case in I’d vote yes to rid Scotland of its feudal landowners and Scots voting no to independence would […]