Iceland, Ireland … and Cyprus

So the debate is on. Should Cyprus leave the euro-area (i.e. issue its own currency)? Alexander Apostolides says No. I’ve suggested recently that even the best-performing of the euro-adjustment group (i.e. Ireland, Spain, Italy, Portugal, Greece and now Cyprus) hasn’t performed as well as the least-well-performing East Asia crisis group. For Cyprus, the comparators are all-too-closer, both in […]

“Internal devaluation” versus “devaluation devaluation”

One more go at the East Asia 1997 versus Euro Area 2008 comparison. The back story is that East Asia underwent a severe crisis in 1997-98, which saw the collapse of its overvalued currency pegs. But, surprise surprise, this “devaluation devaluation” was followed by robust growth. By contrast, the “internal devaluation” (ID) strategy is to achieve the […]

Stylised ‘facts’

Probably for anyone with an expertise not shared widely, there are frustrations about what people seem to “know” about your field. I’ll be less oblique:People seem to “know” that one of the causes of the Great Depression (globally) was competitive devaluation (a.k.a.  “beggar-thy-neighbour” policy). It wasn’t. But let me back up and re-tell the story that […]

To grow or not to grow, (East Asia crisis versus Eurozone crisis)

A friend recently mused that, if the euroarea periphery were not in a single currency area, the crisis we’ve seen so far would look a lot more like the 1997-98 East Asia crisis. Greece would have ‘fallen’, and contagion would have knocked down the remaining ‘weak’ countries. Bear in mind the endogeneity of such contagion: […]

Cyprus

Plenty of good commentary out there. See here and here especially. Cyprus’ EU partners are saying: “Not me — we didn’t insist on a haircut for small depositors.” So Nicosia wanted to protect its position as a banking centre. This is less permissible in view of the fact that it has simultaneously agreed to shrink its banking […]

Un-learning the lessons of Great Depression (ad-infinitum)

This blog is full of lessons-unlearned since the Great Depression. Why so? Because, fortunately or not, I’ve spent a portion of the last several years working on the Great Depression from a monetary and policy perspective. One of the interesting things about that period is the soul-searching it occasioned. This soul-searching is a good place to […]

Abenomics

Abenomics (noun): The use of macro policy to stimulate the economy. See also “Keynesianism”. Japan’s newfound enthusiasm for macro policy is going to provide a helluva interesting real-life test of the competing notions over whether OECD governments are doing too much or too little to tackle anaemic growth rates. My guess is that the austerians will have […]

A macroeconomic union

The euro’s main political effect is to drive a wedge through the EU, something not yet fully understood by the bloc’s policy establishment. The vast majority of insiders still treat it as a regulatory organisation at its heart, rather than as a macroeconomic union.Wolfgang Münchau in today’s FTProps to Münchau for putting so succinctly a sentiment I’ve […]